![]() |
Public/Private Right to Work Pass House and Senate
On,
without a doubt, one of those “I remember when…” days, the GOP-controlled House
of Representatives and Senate both passed “Right to Work” legislation, providing
the ability for members of private and public unions to effectively opt-out.
Weeks
of speculation following the decisive defeat of Proposal 2 (a proposal to place
union organization rights in the Michigan Constitution) on the November ballot
came to a head early Thursday when Governor Rick Snyder, Senate Majority Leader
Randy Richardville (R-Monroe) and Speaker of the House Jase Bolger (R-Marshall)
announced their intentions to move forward on the reform, seen as potentially
devastating to organized labor.
The
House started the action with House
Bill 4054, creating the Right to Work structure for private workers. The
measure passed 58-52 with Republican Representatives Anthony Forlini (Harrison
Township), Ken Goike (Ray Township), Ken Horn (Frankenmuth), Ed McBroom
(Vulcan), Pat Somerville (New Boston) and Dale Zorn (Ida) joining Democrats in
opposition.
Senate
Bill 116 , identical to HB 4054, was moved by the Senate some hours later.
In the upper chamber, GOP Senators Tom Casperson (Escanaba), Mike Green
(Mayville), Mike Nofs (Battle Creek) and Tory Rocca (Sterling Heights) voted
“no” resulting in the 22-16 tally.
The Senate also
passed an amended version of House
Bill 4003 to create the Right to Work environment for public workers.
The House and
Senate plan to concur in each other’s legislation next Tuesday (December 11th),
ultimately moving the bills to the Governor’s desk.
As expected, the
measures exempt police and fire workers and contain a $1 million appropriation
to the Department of Licensing & Regulatory Affairs (LARA) to implement the
new statute, thereby making the law referendum-proof upon enactment.
Chaos at the Capitol
The
protests began well before any gavels were swung as an estimated 2,500 union
members and others opposed to the Right to Work movement descended upon the
Capitol complex Thursday morning – and it wasn’t long before the protests
turned less than peaceful.
Following
the arrest of eight protestors for attempting to rush the Senate floor,
Michigan State Police closed the Capitol for more than five hours, citing
safety concerns. Organized labor sought and received relief through Court
injunction when Judge Joyce Draganchuk ordered the doors opened shortly after
4:30PM as the House began taking action on the legislation.
Further
reports allege that organizations supporting the Right to Work movement were forced
off of the East steps of the Capitol and their signs removed although proper
reservations had been made.
There
have been no reports of injuries related to Thursday’s protests.
Blues Reform Near Enactment
Senate
Bills 1293 and 1294,
the package of bills to turn Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan into a
nonprofit mutual insurance company, passed the House of Representatives
Thursday. The Senate concurred in the House’s changes shortly thereafter, sending
the measures on the Governor’s desk for signature.
Both bills passed the House on 61-49 votes,
with Republican Representatives Joel Johnson (Clare), Tom McMillin (Rochester)
and Chuck Moss (Birmingham) joining Democrats in opposition. The Senate
concurrence votes saw Democratic Senators John Gleason (Flushing) and Virgil
Smith (Detroit) join their GOP colleagues in voting “yes.”
The legislation proposes to change the Blues
into a nonprofit mutual company and treat it largely like any other insurer in
the market. The company would lose its tax exempt status, repeal PA 350, and no
longer have involvement from the Attorney General in rate increase requests.
Further, the proposal calls for the Blues to pay $1.5 billion over 18 years
into an independent nonprofit working towards the overall improvement of the
state’s health.
The House changes included sending more
money, $120 million, to cover Medigap coverage as well as a complete ban on “most
favored nation” clauses beginning in 2014.
House Moves Pieces of RTA Package - Some Left Behind
During one of the more contentious session
days in recent history, three of the five bills in the Regional Transit
Authority legislative package moved from the House of Representatives,
advancing to the Governor’s desk for signature.
The main bill, Senate
Bill 909, passed the House 57-50 on a mostly party-line vote. Two
Democrats, Representative Shanelle Jackson (Detroit) and Lesia Liss (Warren)
supported the legislation which establishes the RTA for metro-Detroit. Nine
Republicans voted no.
Also passing were Senate
Bill 445, setting forth the RTA’s funding, and Senate
Bill 911, which lays the foundation for a regional fee.
Senate
Bills 912 and 967
remain on the House floor awaiting action as the House Democratic Caucus
withheld votes in support of the package in protest to the action being taken
on the Right to Work legislation.
Last Week's Survey Results
The question in last
week’s PAAdvisory asked readers if they believe Michigan should become the
nation’s 24th state to pass “Right to Work” legislation.
62% of respondents answered “no,”
while 38% supported the initiative and answered “yes.”
PAA Government Profiles
For the 97th Legislature (2013-2014), 28 new Michigan House of Representative members will be working in the Capitol. Here are four more of the newest members with more to follow in the coming weeks.
![]() District 40 Michael D. McCready (D) Email: mccready234@gmail.com Occupation: Business owner Age: 51 Predecessor: Chuck Moss (R) ![]() District 41 Martin Howrylak (R) Email: martin@howrylak.com Occupation: CPA Predecessor: Marty Knollenberg (R) ![]() District 48 Pam Faris (D) Email: jcherry@aol.com Occupation: Former Genesee Co. jury board coordinator Age: 55 Predecessor: Richard Hammel (D) ![]() District 52 Gretchen Driskell (D) Email: Gretchen@votegretchen.com Occupation: Saline Mayor Age: 53 Predecessor: Marc Ouimet (R) This Week's Newsletter
Past Newsletters
|