![]() |
96th Legislature Adjourns After Marathon Lame Duck Session
The final gavel was pounded around 4:30AM
Friday, December 14, 2013 and, with it, the session of the 96th Michigan
Legislature has concluded.
Both the House and Senate adjourned session
shortly prior to midnight on Thursday and called the respective chambers back
to order shortly after midnight for what would turn out to be the last “day” of
session.
Arguably the biggest surprise of the lame
duck session came in the form of Senate Bill 810, the U.S. citizenship ballot
question legislation previously vetoed by the Governor. The measure, sponsored
by Senator Geoff Hansen (R-Hart), differs from the original attempt in that it
includes an affirmative statement of citizenship in the signature line rather
than a checkbox on the form.
Some initiatives died with the early morning
adjournment such as efforts to circumvent the Certificate of Need process
enabling McLaren to build a new hospital in Clarkston and the effort to cap
catastrophic claims benefits in auto accidents.
Personal Property Tax Phase-Out Finalized In Dramatic Fashion
Long the top priority of the Snyder
Administration – and championed by Lt. Governor Brian Calley the effort to
eliminate the industrial portion of the personal property tax finally won
legislative approval near the end of the lame duck session, but with a twist.
The entire deal is contingent on voter approval on the August 2014 primary
ballot.
Lawmakers from both sides of the aisle had
voiced their discomfort with the Administration’s proposal based on complexity
and lack of 100% revenue replacement to local units of government – discomfort
that had appeared, early in the week, to potentially knock the train off the
tracks for approval during lame duck. However, a late alternative proposal
initiated by Representative Jeff Farrington (R-Utica) and backed by portions of
the business community and manufacturing lobby resulted in even greater
discomfort among local units – so much so that it resulted in their ultimate
support of the original plan.
The alternative proposal would have simply
exempted all industrial personal property purchased after January 1, 2013 from
the tax, creating an informal phase-out of the tax. Revenue replacement,
however, was not a part of the plan.
The original plan, ultimately passed on close
votes ranging from 58-51 to 56-53, is composed of House Bills 6022, 6024, 6025,
6026 and Senate Bills 1065, 1067, 1068, 1069, 1070 and 1071. Industrial
personal property tax will be phased-out from 2016 to 2022 with 80 percent
revenue replacement going to local governments provided that the lost revenue
equates to at least 2.3 percent of the unit’s total property tax revenue. Local
governments can also replace 100% of lost revenue to police, fire, ambulance
and jail operations through special assessment.
Under the final version of the package, lost
revenue to schools would also be replaced; however, through redistribution of
use tax dollars. A change in the use tax distribution methods, under HB 6026,
requires voter approval and since all bills are tie-barred to HB 6026, in
essence the entire plan requires the same approval.
Public/Private Right To Work Measures Final - Signed
Following
last week’s action, it seemed inevitable – even in the face of an estimated
12,500 protestors in downtown Lansing – and in the end, it was. After the
significant failure of Proposal 12-2 to enshrine the right to collective
bargaining in the state’s Constitution, the Legislature acted and Michigan will
become the country’s 24th “Right to Work” state.
Senate
Bill 116, now Public Act 348 of 2012, prohibits union membership and fee/dues
payment as a condition of employment in the private sector while House
Bill 4003, now PA 349, does the same for public workers. The Governor
signed the two bills less than an hour after their final passage. Since
immediate effect was not achieved on the measures, both will go into effect 90
days after the Legislature adjourns sine die, likely at the end of March.
As expected, the
measures exempt police officers and fire workers and contain an appropriation
to the Department of Licensing & Regulatory Affairs (LARA) to implement the
new statute, thereby making the law referendum-proof upon enactment.
Over
10 thousand protesters converged on Lansing as the legislature moved the
measure to the Governor. With hundreds of State Police Troopers in full riot
gear, relative calm was maintained given the magnitude of the crowd. Only three
arrests were made, all near the Romney Building when protestors reportedly
attempted to enter the building.
One
of the more publicized incidents occurred when Lansing icon Clint Tarver,
everyone’s favorite hot dog guy found vending on the corner of Capitol and
Michigan nearly daily, reportedly had some of his catering equipment damaged
when a tent collapsed on the Capitol lawn. In the following days, the Capitol
community, and observers from around the nation, raised thousands of dollars
for Clint to repair the damages.
New Emergency Manager Statute Headed To Governor's Desk
Following the citizen-initiative referendum
and resulting repeal of Public Act 4 in November, Michigan reverted to the
previously PA 72 for governance of emergency managers appointed to
financially-strapped local units. The Snyder Administration believed; however,
that stronger measures were still needed and got their wish Thursday.
The House version of Senate
Bill 865, introduced by Senator Phil Pavlov (R-St. Clair), was concurred in
by the Senate on a mostly party-line vote and will now be presented to the
Governor for his expected signature. The measure passed 23-15 with Republican
Senators Bruce Caswell (Hillsdale), Mike Kowall (White Lake Township) and Tonya
Schuitmaker (Lawton) joining all Democrats in opposition.
The legislation provides failing local units
(the measure would not affect school districts) with four options: a consent
agreement, an emergency manager, mediation or Chapter 9 bankruptcy.
Lindley To Join PAA January 1
John D. Lindley currently the Vice president
of Government Relations & Regulatory Affairs for the Michigan Association
of CPAs (MACPA), will be joining the Public Affairs Associates team effective
January 1, 2013. John brings a wealth of knowledge in state regulatory,
licensing, and taxation issues and will provide immediate value to PAA clients
with his expertise in association and organizational management.
Having spent the past eleven years with the
18,000-member MACPA, John brings to PAA tested success in political action
committee (PAC) fundraising, strategy development, and grassroots relationship
facilitation.
John graduated from James Madison College at
Michigan State University and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Institute for
Organizational Management at the University of Wisconsin. He previously worked
for the Michigan House of Representatives. John resides
in Holt with his wife, Ann Marie and their daughter Abigail. Everyone as PAA is
excited to welcome John to the team.
Last Week's Survey Results
The question in last
week’s PAAdvisory asked readers who they believed the Democratic nominee to
challenge Governor Rick Snyder will be in 2014.
37.5% believe it will be Lansing
Mayor Virg Bernero, 25% believe it will be U.S. Representative Gary Peters,
12.5% believe it will be Senate Democratic Leader Gretchen Whitmer, and 25%
voted for another candidate.
PAA Government Profiles
District 55
Adam Zemke (D)
Occupation: Automobile company engineer
Age: 28
Predecessor: Rick Olson (R)
District 67
Tom Cochran (D)
Email: www.votetomcochran.com
Occupation: K-12 School Board Member
Age: 59
Predecessor: Barb Byrum (D)
District 68
Andy Schor (D)
Email: andyschor@gmail.com
Occupation: MML Lobbyist
Age: 37
Predecessor: Joan Bauer (D)
District 69
Sam Singh (D)
Email: votesamsingh@gmail.com
Occupation: Former East Lansing Mayor
Age: 41
Predecessor: Tim Meadows (D)
PAAdvisory Briefs
Municipal
Merger Nears
The State Boundary Commission Wednesday voted
to support the merger of Saugatuck and Douglas into one city, moving one step
closer to the first merger of local governmental units in 20 years. Steve
Arwood, Acting Director of the Department of Licensing & Regulatory Affairs
(LARA) will now review the merger, followed by a series of public votes.
Red Wings Arena Aid Addressed
Legislation permitting Detroit Downtown
Development Authority Funds to be directed to a new downtown arena for the
Detroit Red Wings received final passage in the House Thursday – barely. House
Bill 5463, introduced by Representative John Walsh (R-Livonia) passed on a
narrow 58-49 vote with members of the Democratic Caucus and the Detroit
delegation split on the issue – some not voting. The bill now moves to the
Governor for consideration.
Detroit Lighting Authority Package Passes
The Senate version of the Detroit Lighting
Authority legislation received House approval Thursday, despite opposition from
a number of Detroit lawmakers. House
Bill 5688 and House
Bill 5705 passed 60-49 and 61-48, respectively, and moved onto the
Governor’s desk. Senate
Bill 970 was also passed, 59-50, and was returned to the Senate for
enrollment.
This Week's Newsletter
Past Newsletters
|